Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Conclusion to Search for the Perfect Language
  • January 29, 2002
2
Do You Buy It?
  • “Each language constitutes a certain model of the universe, a semiotic system of understanding the world, and if we have 4,000 different ways to describe the world, this makes us rich.  We should be concerned about preserving languages just as we are about ecology.”  -- V.V. Ivanov, Reconstructing the Past
3
Getting to The Linguistics Wars
  • The Stoics: phoneme, morpheme, word
  • Kabbalists: language = mind of God
  • Neogrammarians (took a “physics” approach to  Diachronic Linguistics)
  • Saussure: Language; Synchronic Linguistics
4
Parole
  • The Stoics, and in a very loose way, the kabbalists and neogrammarians concentrated their efforts on sounds, words, writing, listening, and reading language.
  • According to Saussure, linguistics should focus on langue rather than parole.
5
Langue
  • Saussurian and thus modern linguistics focuses on the underlying system/structure that facilitates language.
6
Chomsky & Lull
  • Ars Combinatoria: became a template for generative (transformational) grammar
  • In both systems a limited number of possibilities can be combined to produce a large # of possibilities.  The difference is that Lull’s system produced 729 true propositions, whereas Chomsky’s could theoretically produce every possible linguistic expression – an infinite # of propositions.


7
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
  • Universal Signs (i.e. Chinese): real characters, not necessarily pictographic.


8
"Predicate Calculus:"
  • Predicate Calculus: system of blind thought used to determine truth in things one doesn’t understand.  Chomsky’s generative grammar can be reduced to predicate calculus.


9
What do you mean?
  • Binary Logic: 1 (true), 0 (false); everything can be solved according to this system; credited to Boole.
  • Leibniz found a Chinese text: 1 Ching & referred it to 1 or 0.  It is a textual misinterpretation, but he discovered binary logic.
10
Chomsky & Descartes
  • Descartes was a French philosopher who emphasized reason. Leibniz came after.


  • Chomsky acknowledges an intellectual debt to Descartes.
11
Generativism vs. QAM/PDP
  • Generativism: language structure (deep structure) is intrinsic
  • Parallel Distributed Processing: language is learned


12
"Philology:"
  • Philology: the branch of knowledge that deals with the structure, historical development, and relationships of a language or languages.
  • Linguistics: the scientific study of language and its structure, including the study of grammar, syntax, and phonetics.
  • These definitions from the OED.
13
It’s Time to Get Going.
  • Abstract Due: February 5th
  • 1st Draft Due: March 14th